Extra ordinary claims 12
File Extra ordinary claims
Extra ordinary claims for Behavior
Is the statement: “Identical structure and functioning in the same body for a period of time produces identical behavior for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? No it is not an extra ordinary claim. It logically follows from the “ ” argument and experiments.
Is the statement: “Nearly identical structure and functioning in the same body for a period of time produces identical behavior for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? No it is not an extra ordinary claim. laim. It logically follows from the fact that identical structure andc functioning produces identical behavior and and that there are a very large amount of changes to structure and functioning of matter that are so small that they will not effect the behavior produced by the much more complex whole body “ ” arguments and experiments.
Is the statement: “Identical structure and functioning in the same body for a period of time does not produce identical behavior for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? Yes it is an extra ordinary claim. This is because this statement counters rationality, logic, and experimental results.
follows from the “ ” arguments and experiments.
Is the statement: “Nearly identical structure and functioning in the same body for a period of time does not produce identical behavior for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? Yes it is an extra ordinary claim. This is because this statement counters rationality, logic, and experimental results. And follows from the “ ” arguments and experiments.
Extra ordinary claims for Consciousness
Is the statement: “Identical structure and functioning in the same body for a period of time produces identical consciousness for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? No, because identical and nearly identical structure and functioning produces identical behavior
Is the statement: “Nearly identical structure and functioning in the same body for a period of time produces identical consciousness for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? No because identical and nearly identical structure and functioning produces identical behavior
Is the statement: “Identical structure and functioning in the same body for a period of time does not produce identical consciousness for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? Yes, because identical behavior indicates identical consciousness
Is the statement: “Nearly identical structure and functioning in the same body for a period of time does not produce identical consciousness for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? Yes, because identical behavior indicates identical consciousness
Extra ordinary claims for Ixperiencitness
Is the statement: “Identical structure and functioning of the body for a period of time produces identical ixperiencitness for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim?
Is the statement: “Nearly identical structure and functioning of the body for a period of time produces identical ixperiencitness for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? This statement is not extraordinary claim based on the definition and meaning of the term ixperiencitness. Ixperiencitness being a part of consciousness,
Is the statement: “Identical structure and functioning of the body for a period of time does not produce identical ixperiencitness for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? Yes it is because
Is the statement: “Nearly identical structure and functioning of the body for a period of time does not produce identical ixperiencitness for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? Yes it is because
What is the information that these statements can be based on to determine which one are actually more extraordinary?
Extra ordinary claims for a Person
Is the statement: “The production of identical structure and functioning in a different body for a period of time produces an identical person for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? Yes, because it contradicts the definition of a person as a being a singular body and the definition of identical.
Is the statement: “Nearly identical structure and functioning of the body for a period of time produces an identical person for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? Yes, because it contradicts the definition of a person as a being a singular body and the definition of identical.
Is the statement: “Identical structure and functioning of the body for a period of time does not produce identical ixperiencitness for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? Yes
Is the statement: “Nearly identical structure and functioning of the body for a period of time does not produce identical ixperiencitness for that period of time.” an extraordinary claim? Yes
Is the statement: “Two or more different people can have the same ixperiencitness.” an extraordinary claim? No, first because this statement does not contradict the definitions of the words person or ixperiencitness. Two or more people can produce the same structure and functioning for a period of time Two or more people can produce the same behavior for a period of time. Two or more people can have the same consciousness for a period of time
Is the statement: “Two or more different people can not have the same ixperiencitness.” an extraordinary claim? Yes, because this statement does not contradict the definitions of the words person or ixperiencitness. Because of the following list of arguments