You Never Die

Home/Topics/Arguments

Topic Hub

Arguments

The logical machinery the theory uses to reach its conclusions.

Each argument here is a self-contained reasoning chain. Together they establish that consciousness is substrate-independent and that permanent death is incoherent.

The Three Premises THE THREE PREMISES Three claims science already accepts When you accept all three, the conclusion follows necessarily. 1 Production Brain structure produces consciousness 2 Substrate Independence Identical structure produces identical consciousness 3 Recurrence Patterns can be reproduced across space and time ∴ You cannot permanently die. From the three premises, the conclusion follows.
Arguments overview

Concepts in this Hub

Arguments

2=2 argument

Two identical things can be the same as concepts while different as objects. That gap is why consciousness, which is a pattern, can recur even though a particular brain cannot.

 Arguments

Adjective argument

Consciousness behaves like an adjective, not a noun. It is a property of physical structures, not a separate substance. The argument draws out what follows for personal survival.

 Arguments

Test for originalness argument

If two bodies produce identical consciousness, no test could determine which is the "original". The argument uses that fact to show that originalness is not a real property.

Where this Shows Up in the Book

You Never Die cover

Go all the way

The book treats arguments in full, including the moves and counter-moves this site only sketches.

Get the Book